Oh, gotcha. I totally thought you meant links on his blog he wanted reviewed.
I think your feedback was constructive Mo, thanks for giving it. When people ask for reviews they need to realize they may get opposing views or at least not hear what they want to hear.
That's the purpose of reviews - to see how others view your site.
I remember asking for reviews of this site design over at another forum a couple years ago. (The current design is being changed as we speak).
I had some people tell me all the gold stars made it look like a get-rich-quick site. Everyone knows how much I hate that type of site, so that is not the feedback I wanted to hear at all!
I said... well err... my site's name IS 5 Star, so that's why I have stars.
But I did tone it down a bit and take their feedback into consideration.