Hi Jeremy,
Not sure you realize how valuable Edwin's feedback is and I know the natural tendency in situations like this is to defend you company. However you asked how to get web based affiliates and you just got good feedback from one.
What you may not realize, being new in the business, is that pros and even mid level affiliates have been lied to, ripped off, pitched to and let down more than you could know. So what Edwin tells you is VERY valid because it's his PERCEPTION.
"We are MOST DEFINATELY a real deal group."
When you work in a relationship business, PERCEPTION is 9 tenths of the law. Seriously. Someone could have the best company on the planet but if they unknowingly were sending the wrong message customers could get a COMPLETELY different impression about the company.
I've barely looked at the site, so am not commenting about it specifically. But often marketers build a site from their viewpoint based on what THEY want to say and what THEY think is important, cool or whatever.
In etail to have high conversions you need to think like your customer and view the site as if you were a buyer. With affiliate programs you need to look at the side with your affiliate marketing mindset going. If you are new and don’t know how they think, then it's pretty hard.
You could pay some affiliates to do a focus group, evaluate your site and give you their feedback. But you just got very direct, no holds barred feedback from a strong affiliate. I'd take it and run with it!